7
9 Mill St E, Tottenham, ON L0G 1W0, Canada
New Tecumseth, Ontario L0G 1W0
+19059364224

Iv bought two medium pizza just for it to be super small and super expensive, 51 dollars for two mediums by the way. The pizza tastes like one of those disgusting frozen pizzas boxes that come from walmart. They also lied about their business being brand new. Their little kid was blasting loud music and dancing like a monkey. The place was really tight and there wasnt any room to eat in. Better to go to pizza nova instead, since their two large pizza deals cost 47 dollars, less than their two medium pizzas that were made by little kids and costed 51 dollars. Also they forgot to add the mushrooms even though i asked for extra mushrooms. Do not buy from these cheap people.

This place is amazing at catering! I highly recommend! Professional and upfront on cost, the food was extremely flavorful, and the service top notch. Ruby and Pam are a delight to work with, their expertise in their craft shows. They were cognizant of allergies and restrictions, having options for everyone. We ordered goat curry where the meat fell right off the bone, the saag paneer was extremely tasty, along with the other curries (aloo gobi, channa masala and butter chicken) and the garlic naan was airy. Much appreciate the care and consideration for our special day. Thank you!

I ordered catering appetizers for 50 people, and everything was fantastic! The food was fresh and flavorful—especially the homemade samosas, which were a big hit. Everyone loved the Veg Manchurian as well. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful throughout. Definitely worth trying this place!

Mill St is a fantastic spot if you’re craving a more "Chicago-style" pizza—think toppings tucked under a layer of yummy cheese. Pam and her team are incredibly warm, welcoming, and clearly passionate about crafting great pizza. You can really taste the care they put into every pie. If you haven’t checked them out yet, I highly recommend giving Mill Street a try. Their pizza is seriously worth it!

Always excellent pizza and amazing samosas home made and always fresh!! Chicken wings are also delicious!! The service is also impeccable, they treat you like family!! My go-to pizza shop!!

The customer service and the food were amazing. We had the house special pizza, it was hot and loaded with topping. A must try is the Gulab Jamun with ice cream, amazing. Thank you again, it is worth the drive from Alliston.

We ordered pizza and ceasar salad for lunch today for 20 people at work. It was delicious and Pam was very helpful in helping me figure out how much to order. Will defintely order from there again.

Show Map

Mill St Pizza and Snacks — Pizza restaurant in New Tecumseth

We are glad to greet you!

Mill St Pizza and Snacks

Pizza restaurant at 9 Mill St E, Tottenham, ON L0G 1W0, Canada. Here you will find detailed information about Mill St Pizza and Snacks: address, phone, fax, opening hours, customer reviews, photos, directions and more.

Opening hours

  • Sunday
    12–9 PM
  • Monday
    11 AM–9 PM
  • Tuesday
    11 AM–9 PM
  • Wednesday
    11 AM–9 PM
  • Thursday
    11 AM–9 PM
  • Friday
    11 AM–10 PM
  • Saturday
    11 AM–10 PM

Rating

4
/
5
Based on 7 reviews

Contacts

Categories:
State:
Ontario
Address:
9 Mill St E, Tottenham, ON L0G 1W0, Canada.
City:
New Tecumseth
Phone:
Postcode:
L0G 1W0

About Mill St Pizza and Snacks

Mill St Pizza and Snacks is a Canadian Pizza restaurant based in New Tecumseth, Ontario. Mill St Pizza and Snacks is located at 9 Mill St E, Tottenham, ON L0G 1W0, Canada.


Please contact with Mill St Pizza and Snacks using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Mill St Pizza and Snacks opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.

Are you the owner?
You can make a change to the page:
Edit this page

ALL reviews about Mill St Pizza and Snacks

  • ਲੁੱਚੀ ਆਤਮਾ
    Added 2025.10.17
    Iv bought two medium pizza just for it to be super small and super expensive, 51 dollars for two mediums by the way. The pizza tastes like one of those disgusting frozen pizzas boxes that come from walmart. They also lied about their business being brand new. Their little kid was blasting loud music and dancing like a monkey. The place was really tight and there wasnt any room to eat in. Better to go to pizza nova instead, since their two large pizza deals cost 47 dollars, less than their two medium pizzas that were made by little kids and costed 51 dollars. Also they forgot to add the mushrooms even though i asked for extra mushrooms. Do not buy from these cheap people.
  • Tea Folmeg
    Added 2025.07.20
    This place is amazing at catering! I highly recommend! Professional and upfront on cost, the food was extremely flavorful, and the service top notch. Ruby and Pam are a delight to work with, their expertise in their craft shows. They were cognizant of allergies and restrictions, having options for everyone. We ordered goat curry where the meat fell right off the bone, the saag paneer was extremely tasty, along with the other curries (aloo gobi, channa masala and butter chicken) and the garlic naan was airy. Much appreciate the care and consideration for our special day. Thank you!
  • Supinder Banga
    Added 2025.07.16
    I ordered catering appetizers for 50 people, and everything was fantastic! The food was fresh and flavorful—especially the homemade samosas, which were a big hit. Everyone loved the Veg Manchurian as well. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful throughout. Definitely worth trying this place!
  • Joe Gallo
    Added 2025.06.14
    Mill St is a fantastic spot if you’re craving a more "Chicago-style" pizza—think toppings tucked under a layer of yummy cheese. Pam and her team are incredibly warm, welcoming, and clearly passionate about crafting great pizza. You can really taste the care they put into every pie. If you haven’t checked them out yet, I highly recommend giving Mill Street a try. Their pizza is seriously worth it!
  • Amanda marie
    Added 2025.06.11
    Always excellent pizza and amazing samosas home made and always fresh!! Chicken wings are also delicious!! The service is also impeccable, they treat you like family!! My go-to pizza shop!!
  • Wanda Shedlowich
    Added 2025.06.11
    The customer service and the food were amazing. We had the house special pizza, it was hot and loaded with topping. A must try is the Gulab Jamun with ice cream, amazing. Thank you again, it is worth the drive from Alliston.
  • C B
    Added 2024.01.24
    We ordered pizza and ceasar salad for lunch today for 20 people at work. It was delicious and Pam was very helpful in helping me figure out how much to order. Will defintely order from there again.
  • By owner
    Added 2024.01.28
    Thank you for your feedback Cheryl. We are so glad that you and your guests enjoyed the food . Look forward to serving you again in future
Leave your own review about Mill St Pizza and Snacks:
Add a review

You Might Also Consider

Pizzaiolo
Pizza restaurant in Ontario
7 reviews
70 Victoria St E, Alliston, ON L9R 1L2, Canada.
Pizza Hut
Pizza restaurant in Ontario
7 reviews
130 Mill St E, New Tecumseth, ON L0G 1W0, Canada.
Eddies Pizza
Pizza restaurant in Ontario
7 reviews
208 Victoria St E, Alliston, ON L9R 1K6, Canada.